Undergoing four or more CT scans more than doubles a pediatric patient's risk of developing certain cancers.

Four or more CT scans double risk of children developing certain cancers

April 27, 2023
by John R. Fischer, Senior Reporter
In a new paper, Taiwanese researchers are reemphasizing the need for ensuring pediatric patients only undergo CT imaging when necessary to avoid overexposing them to radiation, having found that scanning children four or more times more than doubles their risk of developing certain cancers.

Comparing data on 7,807 children under 18 diagnosed with intracranial tumors, leukemia or lymphoma between 2000 and 2013, and 78,057 control subjects, they found that one CT scan had no increased risk of any cancers compared with no exposure, but that two- to three- scans raised the chances of developing intracranial tumors. Those who received four or more had over a two-fold risk of being diagnosed with intracranial tumors, leukemia, and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

"Parents and pediatric patients should be well informed on risks and benefits before radiological procedures and encouraged to participate in decision-making around imaging,” wrote Dr. Yu-Hsuan Joni Shao, of the College of Medical Science and Technology at Taipei Medical University, and her coauthors, in their report.

The authors say that younger children appear to be more at risk of developing cancer from repeated CT scans, and that providers should be careful in their use of this technology and consider using radiation-reducing techniques.

Reducing unnecessary exposure can be achieved through a variety of means, one of which is adopting and abiding by guidelines and standards around appropriate imaging.

The ALARA (As Low As Reasonably Achievable) Principle, for instance, introduced by the International Commission on Radiological Protection in 1977, ensures that patients are exposed to minimum radiation levels during imaging, and spares them from any excess radiation that does not have a direct benefit. It advises that providers minimize time spent performing exams as much as possible, as well as distancing themselves from radioactive sources, and using appropriate shielding technologies and resources to protect themselves and patients, according to the CDC.

But following this risks decreasing the quality of CT images, hindering results. Optimization strategies like creating reference CT images by scanning specifically designed phantoms can help clinicians decipher a balance between radiation exposure and the amount of machine power needed to produce quality CT scans, but tasks like this are often manual and time-consuming.

In March, researchers at the University of Florence and radiologists and medical physicists from Florence Hospital automated this process with AI, creating a data set of 30,000 labeled CT images captured with different tomographic reconstruction configurations performed on phantoms that mimicked human tissue. They trained two AI models on these configurations and then tested them to see if they assessed CT images as well as humans.

“Our results were very promising, as both trained models performed remarkably well and achieved an absolute percentage error of less than 5%. This indicated that the models could identify the object inserted in the phantom with similar accuracy and confidence as a human professional, for almost all reconstruction configurations and abnormalities sizes and contrasts,” wrote lead researcher Dr. Sandra Doria, from the University of Florence’s physics department, in her study, which will be part of the JMI Special Issue on Medical Image Perception and Observer Performance.

Additionally, reviewing, creating and adapting guidelines and integrating them into the technological process may not only reduce exposure without affecting outcomes, but also cut expenses for providers.

Clinicians at the Pediatric Trauma Center at UR Medicine Golisano Children’s Hospital in New York did just this by adapting existing guidelines for head, neck and abdomen/pelvis, and developing new ones for the chest area that cut unnecessary imaging in half, according to their study published in the Journal of Pediatric Surgery.

These insights demonstrate that in order to reduce repetitive CT imaging and associated risks of developing cancer, it is essential to enforce these standard guidelines for appropriate imaging, and ensure providers have access to the necessary technologies, resources and funding to automate the processes for reducing unnecessary radiation exposure so that clinicians are more motivated to integrate them into their practices.

The findings of the Taiwanese study were published in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal).